Can the Insurance Company Use My Facebook and Instagram Photos Against My Slip and Fall Claim?

They can look at and use anything you posted publicly, and if your claim turns into a lawsuit a New York court can order you to turn over posts that are genuinely relevant to your injuries. What they cannot do is force you to hand over your private Facebook and Instagram just because an adjuster asked. The safest moves right now are simple: do not delete anything, set your accounts to private, and route the request through a lawyer instead of answering it yourself.

No. An adjuster asking for your social media is a request, not a court order, and you do not have to grant it. You should not give login access to anyone connected to the claim, and you should not accept a friend or follower request from a name you do not recognize during an open case, because investigators do reach for that.

The insurer is entitled to two things and no more. It can see whatever is public on your profiles. And later, only if the case becomes a lawsuit, it can ask a judge to order posts that are relevant to your injuries. Browsing your entire private account on demand is not one of the things it gets. When the request comes in informally, the right answer is to send it to your attorney, not to open your phone and start scrolling for them.

When you say a wet floor left you with a hurt back, knee, hip, shoulder, or wrist, the adjuster goes looking for anything that makes you look more active than you claim to be. A photo of you carrying grocery bags. A cousin's wedding where you are on your feet. A weekend trip. Playing with your kids in the yard. A gym check-in from before the fall with the date quietly ignored.

None of that proves your injury is fake. A person with a real back injury still smiles at a party and still lifts a child for a moment because they have to. The problem is that the picture arrives on the adjuster's desk with all of that context stripped away, and it becomes a reason to offer you less. They also read your tags, your check-ins, your location data, and your comments. A caption like "feeling great today" gets screenshotted and saved. That's the whole game: collect small moments, strip the context, and use them to question how hurt you really are.

This is the mistake that hurts people the most, and it is the opposite of what instinct tells you to do.

Once you have an injury claim, your posts are potential evidence. If you delete them or deactivate the account after the fact, the other side can argue you destroyed evidence, and a New York court can penalize you for it, sometimes by instructing the jury to assume the missing posts were bad for you. That penalty can cost you more than the post ever would have. There is a clean line here that is easy to hold: making an account private is fine, deleting the content is not. If you already posted about the fall, leave it alone and tell your lawyer what is out there so it can be handled the right way.

If you take nothing else from this page, take this short list and do it today:

If the claim becomes a lawsuit, your social media can be part of discovery in New York. It isn't unlimited, though, and your state's rules are not the same as the general advice you'll find floating around online.

New York's highest court settled the standard in 2018 in Forman v. Henkin. There is no special higher bar for social media. Courts apply the ordinary discovery test and allow the other side to obtain posts that are relevant to the injuries you are claiming, weighed against your privacy. A judge does not hand the defense your whole private account to read at will. A demand for everything usually gets narrowed to what genuinely bears on the case, and the court can review material privately before deciding what has to be produced.

That's exactly why the request belongs with a lawyer. Ignore it and you invite a motion to compel. Over-share and you hand the insurer material a judge would never have ordered you to give. A lawyer answers it in a way that protects both your case and your privacy.

While the insurer is busy asking about your Instagram, the proof that actually decides a supermarket fall is sitting on the store's side, and it does not last.

The surveillance video of that wet floor. The cleaning and inspection logs that show whether anyone checked the aisle. Prior complaints about the same spot. The incident report you filled out at the customer service desk. Store camera footage is often written over within weeks, which means the record that could win your case can quietly disappear while everyone is looking at your vacation photos. To hold a New York store responsible you generally have to show it created the hazard, or knew about it and failed to fix or warn, and that story lives in those records, not on your phone.

There is also the fault question, because owners lean on it hard. They argue the spill was open and obvious and that you were not watching where you were going. New York uses comparative negligence, so even if some fault gets assigned to you, it reduces what you recover rather than ending the claim. A Brooklyn slip and fall claim is built by sending a preservation demand for the footage and the maintenance logs before they are gone, which matters far more to your case than any photo you did or did not post.

Karasik Law Group, P.C. has approximately 19 years of experience in personal injury law and handles slip and fall cases across all five boroughs and New Jersey. Alexander Karasik, Esq. conducts the free consultations personally, and clients reach their attorney directly by phone, text, email, or in person rather than through a case manager. The firm requests the surveillance footage and maintenance records before a property owner can erase them, and it deals with the adjuster and any social media request directly, so you are not answering the insurer alone. The team works with clients in Russian, Ukrainian, English, and Spanish, and can meet you at home or in the hospital if getting around is hard right now.

The fee follows the case. Karasik Law Group, P.C. takes slip and fall matters on contingency, advances the costs of the case, and you pay nothing unless and until there is a recovery. You can read more about what you can recover in a personal injury case before you decide anything.

Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. If an adjuster has asked for your social media, reach the office for a free case review before you respond or delete a single post.

The other side may already have screenshots, which is one more reason not to delete now. Set everything to private going forward and tell your lawyer what is already out there so it can be addressed.

Yes. The private-settings rule and the do-not-delete rule apply from the day you have a claim. The court-ordered discovery part only comes up if the matter turns into a lawsuit.

Yes, if those posts are public or they tag you. Ask people to hold off on posting about you or your accident until the case is done.

No. Deactivating or deleting can look like destroying evidence and can be penalized. Go private and go quiet instead.

Attorney Advertising